I am not naming the influencer because the point is not the individual. The point is the structural pattern. The routine in question was posted as a “skin transformation regimen for combination skin with hyperpigmentation.” Fourteen steps, twice a day. The creator has roughly two million followers. The video has been watched seven million times. Here is the audit.
The routine as posted
Morning: oil cleanse, foam cleanse, exfoliating toner, hydrating toner, essence, vitamin C serum, brightening serum, peptide serum, eye cream, moisturizer, lip mask, sunscreen, setting spray, primer. Evening: balm cleanse, oil cleanse, foam cleanse, exfoliating toner, hydrating toner, essence, niacinamide serum, retinol serum, eye cream, sleeping mask, lip mask, neck cream.
Twenty-six product applications across the day. I clocked it at thirty-eight minutes by stopwatch when I tried it myself for two weeks.
The five steps doing real work
Foam cleanse. Removed grime, oil, and SPF. Necessary. Doing what it claims.
Vitamin C serum. 15% L-ascorbic acid at a reasonable pH. Genuine antioxidant signal in the morning. Real product, real role.
Retinol serum at night. Encapsulated 0.3%, used three nights a week per the creator’s own caption. Reasonable dose, reasonable frequency. Real work.
Moisturizer. Ceramide-glycerin base. Doing the job.
Sunscreen. Mineral broad-spectrum SPF 50. The single most important product in the routine for the stated goal of treating hyperpigmentation. Without it, none of the rest matters.
The four duplicates
Oil cleanse and balm cleanse, both used in the evening. Two products with the same function and substantially the same mechanism. The second is doing nothing the first did not do.
Exfoliating toner and brightening serum, both morning. The toner is a low-percentage glycolic. The brightening serum contains lactic acid and niacinamide. Two acid exposures, twice a day, in a routine that also contains a retinol three nights a week. This is barrier abuse, not exfoliation strategy.
Hydrating toner and essence, both stages. Both are 90% water plus glycerin plus humectant. The second one is the first one in a more expensive bottle.
Eye cream and moisturizer. The face moisturizer is appropriate for the eye area. The eye cream is a 15ml version of the same base with $40 added to the price.
The three inert decorations
Lip mask. Pleasant, harmless, not part of any skin goal. Counts as ritual, not treatment.
Setting spray and primer. Both are mostly water plus silicone and have nothing to do with the skin-health goal stated. They serve makeup, not skin.
Neck cream. Same formulation as the face moisturizer in a different tube.
The two steps undermining the goal
This is the part that matters most.
The exfoliating toner used twice a day, stacked with the brightening serum (which also exfoliates), stacked with retinol three nights a week, is putting the skin into a state of low-grade chronic irritation. The stated goal of the routine is treating hyperpigmentation. Inflamed skin pigments more, not less. The over-exfoliation is actively making the hyperpigmentation worse over time, even as it produces a short-term “smoother” feel that reads on camera as improvement.
The second is the foam cleanse on top of the oil cleanse on top of the balm cleanse in the evening. Three cleanses, including two with surfactants, strips lipid from skin that needs lipid to maintain the barrier. A compromised barrier inflames. Inflamed skin pigments. The cleansing routine and the pigmentation goal are at war.
The contrarian section: the routine is not for skin, it is for content
The thing nobody says out loud is that long routines exist for video. Twenty-six product applications fills four minutes of content. Five product applications fills forty seconds. The platform rewards the longer one. The skin does not.
If you were genuinely trying to treat combination skin with hyperpigmentation, the working routine would be roughly six products. Foam cleanse. Vitamin C serum in the morning. Moisturizer. SPF 50 reapplied. Oil cleanse and gentle cleanse in the evening. Retinol three nights, optional gentle exfoliating acid one night. Done.
The six-product version is not a video. It is a habit. Habits do not get watched seven million times.
What a useful version of this routine would look like
Audit your own version of the influencer routine and ask, for every step, what specific problem is this solving and is it duplicating another step. The duplicates collapse fast. The decorations leave once you notice them. The undermining steps are usually obvious in retrospect — too many cleanses, too many acids, too many actives — but invisible while the routine is in flight.
For the underlying philosophy, the slow skincare manifesto covers the rest. The 12-step critique and active-list piece sit alongside this argument.
What I use after the audit
The everyday routine I have settled on is five products. A gentle cleanser. The Microbiome Glow Serum in the morning for the postbiotic calming work. SPF, reapplied. An evening cleanse. A peptide-rich barrier cream like BioCell Renewal Cream at night, with a bakuchiol or low-dose acid alternating two nights a week. That is the routine.
FAQ
Are all long routines bad? No. There are long routines built carefully by people who genuinely understand their skin. The trouble is most of the long routines you see online are built for retention metrics, not for results.
How do I tell which steps in my own routine are duplicating? List every product. For each, write down its primary mechanism (cleansing, hydrating, exfoliating, antioxidant, retinoid, peptide, occlusive, etc.). Anywhere you have two products doing the same mechanism, one of them is a duplicate.
What if I love the ritual of a long routine? Then keep the ritual without all the actives. Decorative steps that bring you pleasure are fine. Active duplicates that compromise your barrier are not.
Will the influencer push back on this audit? Maybe. The deeper issue is that the routine is doing something other than what its stated goal claims. That is the structural problem, regardless of who is posting it.
Is there a number of steps that is just right? The number is whatever the smallest routine is that solves your specific named concerns. For most adult faces, that is between four and six.
Sources
- Draelos ZD. “Cosmetic dermatology: products and procedures.” 2nd edition, Wiley-Blackwell, 2015.
- American Academy of Dermatology. “Hyperpigmentation.” aad.org
- British Association of Dermatologists. “Topical treatment guidance.” 2024 edition.
Tag hub: All skincare-myths coverage