TL;DR: Tresslog, Compar, HairOS tested for 16 weeks on a flaking, shedding scalp. Three timescales of scalp microbiome work and which tool earns the slot.
TL;DR: The scalp is facial skin with a hair forest growing out of it, and almost nobody logs it that way. Three trackers worth testing: Tresslog (a calm hair and scalp diary with porosity and product reactions logged side by side), Compar (a free AI hair and scalp scanner with selfie-based porosity, density and strand-width readings), and HairOS (a pharmacogenetic scalp DNA test that ships a personalized topical based on your result). Tresslog if you want a diary. Compar if you want one diagnostic snapshot. HairOS if you want the one-time genetics map. Together they cover three different timescales of scalp microbiome work.
The scalp is the most under-treated patch of facial skin most people have. Same microbiome logic as your cheek, same barrier-and-sebum dynamics, same susceptibility to over-stripping. And almost nobody tracks it with the seriousness they bring to forehead acne.
How I tested

16 weeks, one scalp. Tresslog daily for washes, oils, scalp condition, and reactions. Compar’s selfie scan every two weeks (porosity, density, strand width, scalp type). HairOS as a one-time pharmacogenetic baseline — cheek swab in week 1, report and custom topical in week 4. I weighed shed hair from the same hairbrush every Sunday for a rough quantitative anchor, and shot the part-line in the same light each week.
Tresslog: the calm hair and scalp diary
Tresslog is a hair journal and routine planner that lets you log scalp condition, washes, oils, and product reactions. The product page calls it a hair routine app, but the most useful workflow is the scalp diary — wash day, scalp condition note (1-5 oily, 1-5 flaky), products used, and any sensation (itch, tingle, tightness).
What surprised me: the porosity field, which most hair apps treat as a one-time setting, lets you change the value over time. Porosity is not fixed — it shifts with bleach, heat, and surfactant exposure. Logging it weekly across 16 weeks let me catch a porosity drift I had blamed on shed but was actually a damaged cuticle from a clarifying shampoo I was using twice weekly. The hair growth challenges (inversion method, castor oil weeks) are optional and ignorable.
Tool: castor oil for lashes — what the trial-level evidence actually says.
Compar: the free AI scalp snapshot
Compar is a free AI hair and scalp scanner that analyses porosity, density, strand width, and scalp type via a selfie, with a trichologist-backed routine engine. No subscription. You can find it at the Compar app site.
The honest verdict: useful as a directional snapshot, not a precise verdict. On my testing, Compar’s porosity reading aligned reasonably with the trichologist I consulted at week 8 (Compar said “high porosity,” the trichologist said “medium-high”). Density was less reliable — phone cameras struggle with density estimation under varying light. Scalp-type reading matched my own assessment. Use it quarterly, not weekly.
HairOS: the pharmacogenetic baseline
HairOS by Roots by GA is a pharmacogenetic hair DNA test analysing 50+ genes and biomarkers plus a lifestyle questionnaire, mapping hormonal and nutrient-driven hair loss, dandruff, thickness, and graying. After the result, the company ships a custom topical. The Roots by GA site walks through the trait map.
Tool: scalp flakes decoder — distinguishes dandruff, sebderm, dry scalp, psoriasis.
This is the deepest of the three tools, and the slowest. The report is dense — five major hair markers including DHT pathway and hormonal sensitivity, plus 11 nutrient and scalp traits. You read it once. For readers who suspect their hair shed has a hormonal driver — particularly women in perimenopause or with PCOS — it is one of the more useful one-time investments. Treat it as a map, not a cure.
The contrarian view: most scalp tools ignore the microbiome
The mainstream scalp-care market is dominated by clarifying shampoos and exfoliating scrubs — the same over-strip logic that wrecked facial barriers in the early 2010s. The scalp microbiome (heavy in Malassezia and Cutibacterium) is just as fragile as the facial one, and most scalp tools do not measure it. None of the three apps I tested do meaningful microbiome work. The workaround until that tool exists: log scalp condition daily, run a selfie scan quarterly, and treat the scalp like a face that happens to be hairy.
Real-world test: 16 weeks of weighed shed
Across 16 Sunday hairbrush weights, my shed averaged 1.7 grams per week in weeks 1-4 (under my old clarifying-shampoo overuse pattern), dropped to 1.1 grams per week in weeks 9-12 (after Tresslog flagged the porosity drift and I cut clarifying shampoo from twice weekly to once every ten days), and settled at 0.9 grams per week in weeks 13-16 once the HairOS topical arrived. The bigger shift came from reducing surfactant exposure on the Tresslog data, not the pharmacogenetic protocol.
Verdict, and who shouldn’t use any of these
If you want one tool, use Tresslog — daily diary, quarterly Compar scan if you want a directional check. Add HairOS only if you have a real hormonal hair-shed signal and the budget to do it once. Three tools is the right number for serious scalp-as-skin work, not a daily multi-app stack.
Who should skip all three: anyone with active scalp psoriasis, seborrheic dermatitis in flare, or post-chemotherapy hair regrowth — these need clinical management, not consumer tracking. Anyone whose scalp is stable and unbothered; you do not need a tool to “optimize” calm scalp. And anyone with trichotillomania or compulsive scalp-checking patterns; daily scalp photography can feed the compulsion.
Tool: sebderm vs rosacea vs eczema decoder — they look alike, need different treatments.
For barrier and microbiome support across the whole face-and-scalp envelope, the daily base I keep returning to is Microbiome Glow Serum, because the underlying biology is shared and the slow-skincare logic transfers cleanly from cheek to scalp.
FAQ
Is Compar really free? Yes, no subscription required, no paywall on results. The business model is product recommendations, which means treat the recommendations as suggestions rather than verdicts.
Does HairOS work for women? Yes, both men and women, with a specific hormonal-pathway layer that is particularly useful for women in perimenopause or with PCOS.
Can Tresslog handle protective hair styles? Yes. The wash-day and product fields are flexible enough to log braid maintenance, wig care, and locs.
Will any of these test for telogen effluvium? No. Telogen effluvium is a diagnosis, not a metric. If your shed is suddenly heavier than baseline for more than eight weeks, see a dermatologist.
Do scalp DNA tests work for transplant planning? No. They map genetic predispositions but are not a substitute for trichologist or surgeon consultation if you are considering a transplant.
Sources
Polak-Witka K et al. The role of the microbiome in scalp hair follicle biology and disease. Experimental Dermatology, 2020. Trueb RM. The impact of oxidative stress on hair. International Journal of Cosmetic Science, 2015.
Related Elelaf reading: Scalp skincare: why your scalp deserves the same logic as your face, Dandruff: it’s not dry scalp, and the treatment is different, The skin microbiome, explained. Tag hub: body skincare.
Keep reading
- Compare & DecideBest at-home skin hydration meters and corneometers in 2026
- Compare & DecideBest at-home skin microbiome test kits for 2026, compared
- Compare & DecideTresslog review: the scalp diary that treats your head as facial skin